Thailand's 2 big islands compared on 8 criteria. Here's which one is right for you.
In a nutshell
- Phuket: lively, nightlife, easy to reach
- Koh Samui: calmer, jungle, retreats
Beaches
Phuket: varied, from the big ones (Patong) to beautiful hidden coves (Freedom)
Koh Samui: Chaweng = big, Lamai = laid-back, Bophut = chic
→ It's a draw
Nightlife
Phuket's Patong: THE party destination in Thailand
Koh Samui: Chaweng is decent but 5x smaller
→ Phuket wins
Peace and quiet
Southern Phuket (Nai Harn, Kata Noi): fine
Koh Samui: the whole jungle interior, full of retreats
→ Koh Samui wins
Excursions
Phuket: Phi Phi, Phang Nga, James Bond, Similan
Koh Samui: Ang Thong, Koh Tao, Koh Phangan
→ Phuket wins (variety)
Getting there
Phuket: large airport, direct flights from the Middle East, low-cost carriers
Koh Samui: small airport, Bangkok Airways monopoly = expensive
→ Phuket wins
Our verdict
Phuket: if you've never been to Thailand, or want variety
Koh Samui: couples after a zen retreat, spa experiences
Ideal: combine the two over 14 days